When Tenants Want to Provide Their Own Credit Report
Friday, October 1st, 2010Sandy is a landlord who regularly checks the criminal and credit backgrounds of potential tenants. She’s noticing a new trend lately: more and more lease applicants show up with credit reports in hand.
While she was impressed that folks were keeping tabs on their own credit records, she was also suspicious and concerned:
- Why were they trying to keep her from running her own tenant background and credit check?
- Was she obligated to accept these credit reports?
Sandy’s first inclination was that the credit reports could be falsified. “It’s pretty easy these days for anyone with computer skills to design a professional-looking credit report. It could be completely made up.”
Her next worry was that the date could be wrong. “The last one I saw said it was only a few days old, but it would be easy to change the year from 2000 to 2010. It could have been a ten-year-old credit report.”
Sandy’s main frustration was that some potential tenants were insisting she accept the credit reports instead of running her own. As it turns out, she’s probably safe to refuse the self-supplied tenant credit reports. In most states, landlords are under no obligation to accept them. The obvious reason is that they can be easily altered. There are some exceptions, so be sure to check your local and state laws for details in your area.
While frustrated tenants may complain about paying a background check fee each time they apply for an apartment or rental house, it’s a fact that a bad credit history hurts one’s pocketbook. When a credit check comes back acceptable, the next step is to sign a lease. Only the negative reports require tenants to apply for another lease at another rental property, and pay another fee. The cycle is difficult to break, but it doesn't obligate landlords to accept a tenant’s own credit report.